Certainly, there will be all sorts of dissatisfaction with the verdict. So, the question arises: the defendant is a judge, and the one hamring the gavel is also a judge. What kind of chemical reaction will occur between these two?
The more I thought about it, the more interesting it seed!
The day before the trial, another matter ca up.
Hongtong Property Managent Company was added by Lanhe Court as a third party without independent claim rights.
The reason is that they hadn't paid social security for three years, which is also one of the reasons why the plaintiff was unable to enjoy social security. Therefore, it was legally added.
Li Chang'an was completely numb, thinking how such a thing could happen just because of a cleaner.
Originally, he wanted to send Jiang Shubo, but after thinking about it, he decided to let the HR manager, Old Bai, appear in court.
If the matter could be managed, it wouldn't be impossible...
Finally, the day of the trial arrived. Old Tang, briefcase in hand, appeared at the entrance of the courthouse, casually remarking, "Let say this first, don't shoot my face. If I see anyone publishing pictures of my face online later on, you all know what the consequences will be."
Today's event was drawing a lot of attention, with quite a few dia outlets at the entrance of the courthouse. So held smartphones, others video caras, always at the forefront of chasing hot topics. Stay connected via m-v l|e'-
Just look at so matters that no one cares about on ordinary days; as soon as they get hot, internet celebrities rush to cash in on them.
While speaking, Old Tang naturally walked into the courthouse. Those taking pictures put down their phones and dared not continue. Tang Fangjing was never one to bluff.
Because if he said he would sue you, he certainly would...
Old Tang entered the civil tribunal of Lanhe County's courthouse and took his place as the plaintiff.
The clerk was already tidying things up, looking at Tang Fangjing without speaking, with what seed to be complicated feelings.
Finally, the people from Anlong District Court arrived. Two of them, one of whom looked to be in his forties, with a receding hairline that testified to his determination.
The other one was younger; the commonality between them was that both looked unhappy.
Nobody from Anlong District Court wanted to handle this case. Win or lose, it would be embarrassing.
But to comply with the conditions—that too was impossible, so they had to co in this reluctant manner.
The man with the receding hairline was a judge from Anlong District Court, surnad Gao. Precisely because he was a judge, he understood how difficult it really was.
The clerk had begun to read out the courtroom discipline. After finishing, everyone stood up, and the mbers of the collegiate panel entered and took their seats.
At the sa ti, the live broadcast signal was connected to the online public courtroom.
There were also not a few observers at the scene of the court hearing, so of whom had run over from Handong just for amusent.
There were too many who wanted to observe, and the courtroom at Lanhe Court was too small. In the end, they even had to make a reservation...
Online, netizens were flocking into the live broadcast room, with various comnts flying across the screen.
"Here it cos, here it cos, can soone knowledgeable tell us if the defendant's side includes a judge?"
"Why do we always have to bother the knowledgeable? But yes, the one on the opposite side is indeed a judge."
"Oh my god, I'm so nervous, why hasn't it started yet?"
Amidst the bustling discussions, preparations in front of the court were slowly advancing.
The Judgnt Chief declared the court in session, confird the identities of both parties, whether there were any objections, requests for recusal, and so on.
After completing the routine procedures, the stage for court investigation began, and the parties comnced their statents.
Old Tang spoke first, "Our client has been involved in cleaning services at the court since 2002... up until the year '19. During this period, Anlong District Court had never paid social security."
"Because of this, after our client was dismissed by Hongtong Company due to reaching the statutory retirent age, he couldn't enjoy the pension benefits, and it was confird by the Social Security Departnt of Anlong District that it was no longer possible to pay the contributions retrospectively."
"Having failed to resolve the issue through coordination with Anlong District Court, he filed a lawsuit..."
The core causal relationship was, the court didn't pay for social security, which led to the current inability to enjoy pension benefits, and no possibility to make retrospective paynts. Therefore, the court should take responsibility!
How to assu this responsibility? Simple, just calculate the monthly paynt as if social security had been paid normally and then the court should pay that amount each month until the opposing party passes away.
Logically, there's no issue. If you're responsible for causing the problem, then you bear that responsibility.
The balding Old Gao began his defense.
By this point, to deny that Li Yong's mother had worked in the court was foolish, given that the evidence could prove the existence of the employnt relationship.
Moreover, upon glancing at the list of evidence and witness testimonies, Old Gao didn't even want to speak anymore.
The person in charge of the logistics center of the court back in '02 had been brought out as a witness...
Such matters were certainly demanded by Lanhe Court, and the opposition couldn't refuse.
Moreover, according to relevant regulations, the employer is obliged to provide proof of salary paynts and attendance records. If the employer can't provide them, they have to bear the responsibility for failure to present evidence.
Therefore, Old Gao's defense focused on the allocation of responsibility.
"In 2002, the system for employing temporary workers was generally unstandardized, so this should be considered a historical problem. It shouldn't be vaguely presud that the court should bear all the responsibility. Historical reasons at the ti must be considered..."
"Besides, during the last three years, the court had already outsourced the cleaning services, so the outsourcing company should also bear responsibility..."
With the defense concluded, the evidence submission and examination began.
Old Tang on the other side had already completely relaxed, holding a winning hand. Even if Old Song took over right then, the victory was assured.
"Evidence one, testimonies from the then deputy director of the logistics managent center of Anlong District Court, as well as three cleaning staff who were working at the ti..."
"Evidence two, work photos taken by Anlong District Court in '05."
Reviews
All reviews (0)