Edmund Erwell descended into the Society’s vaults alone.
He’d dismissed the guards at the third level, sent his assistant back to prepare the Council chamber. This was work he needed to do himself. Had to do himself. Because in forty years of docunting corrupted wielders and dangerous artifacts, he’d never personally sealed away sothing like the Perfection Slicer.
It had heavy sins:
This was a Legendary Tool that broke the world before the Cataclysm, and hallowed out Greaves for over seven years.
It would have taken Marron as well, if not for extraordinary intervention.
The stairs descended past the public archives—levels one through three, where scholars could request access to study approved artifacts. Past the restricted collections on levels four and five, where dangerous-but-docunted items were stored under lock and key. Past the hazardous materials vault on level six, where artifacts that leaked magic or radiation were contained in lead-lined boxes.
Down to level seven. The deepest vault. The forgotten place.
Edmund’s lantern was the only light. The walls were bare stone here, no decorations, no comfort. Just iron doors set into rock, each one marked with a date and a catalogue number. Behind those doors: the tools and artifacts too dangerous to study, too powerful to destroy, too corrupted to risk even limited access.
The failures. The tragedies. The proof that so knowledge was better left buried.
Edmund stopped at the last door. Vault Seven-Seventeen. Empty for three decades, waiting for the next tragedy.
He set down his lantern and the wrapped Slicer. His hands were shaking—age, or emotion, or both. He’d carried this burden for so long. Docunted so many cases. Warned so many wielders. Watched so many of them fall anyway.
And now he held in his hands the tool that had started it all.
"I know you’re awake in there," Edmund said to the wrapped bundle. His voice echoed in the stone chamber. "Marcus’s report said the mandoline goes dormant without an active wielder, but I’ve studied enough artifacts to know—dormant isn’t the sa as sleeping. You’re listening. Aware. So listen carefully."
He began unwrapping the tool, slowly, carefully. Layer after layer of canvas and leather fell away until the mandoline lay exposed in his hands.
It was beautiful and terrible in equal asure. Dark tal, multiple adjustable blades, intricate chanisms for controlling slice thickness. Pre-Cataclysm craftsmanship at its finest. A tool designed for perfect, uniform cuts—the kind of precision that should have elevated cuisine, improved food preservation, advanced culinary science.
Instead, it had created a monster.
"I’m going to seal you away," Edmund said, examining the blades. "In this vault, behind four locks, with three separate binding spells. You’ll stay here until I’m dead, and probably long after. The next Director of the Society will have to decide what to do with you. And the one after that. You’ll be passed down like a curse, a warning, a reminder of what happens when tools forget to teach wisdom."
The mandoline was completely dark. No red glow. No pulses. Just cold tal.
But Edmund could feel sothing from it. Not consciousness exactly—more like potential. Awareness waiting for connection. Like a fire banked low, ready to roar back to life the mont soone provided fuel.
"Greaves will confess tomorrow," Edmund continued. "After the Council votes on Marron’s case. He’ll tell them everything—every victim, every client, every atrocity you made possible. The authorities will execute him. Probably publicly. They’ll want people to see that justice was done, that monsters face consequences."
He traced one of the mandoline’s blades with a careful finger. Sharp. Perfectly sharp, even after everything.
"But you’re the real monster, aren’t you?" Edmund’s voice was quiet. "Greaves was just a man. Weak, yes. Morally compromised, certainly. But human. You’re the one who taught him that humanity didn’t matter. That efficiency was everything. That cutting is just cutting, whether it’s carrots or people."
Edmund set the mandoline down on the floor and reached into his coat. He pulled out a small leather journal—worn, well-used. His personal docuntation of the seventeen cases. The wielders who’d been corrupted by Legendary Tools over the past forty years.
"I’m going to read you sothing," he said, opening the journal to a marked page. "Case Fourteen. Theo Marris. Age twenty-three. Trained patissier at the Lurian Culinary Institute. Brilliant student. Kind heart. My student’s best friend."
His voice roughened slightly.
"Theo acquired what we think was a Lesser Legendary Tool—not one of the seven originals, but sothing from the sa era. A set of asuring spoons that promised perfect precision. Every ingredient asured exactly, every ratio optimized, every result flawless."
Edmund’s hands tightened on the journal.
"Within six months, Theo was working twenty-hour days. Destroying entire batches if a single elent was imperfect. Screaming at anyone who suggested he rest, that ’good enough’ was ever acceptable. The spoons taught him that perfection was the only goal, that anything less was failure. And he believed them."
He turned the page, though he had the entry morized.
"At month eight, Theo had a complete breakdown. Couldn’t function. Couldn’t work. Couldn’t even hold a conversation without talking about perfect asurents and optimal ratios. We took the spoons away, locked them up. But the damage was done. He’s been in a rest ho for three years now. Sotis he has good days. Mostly he just—" Edmund’s voice cracked. "Mostly he just stares and mutters about precision."
Edmund closed the journal, set it beside the mandoline.
"You did worse than that to Greaves. The spoons broke Theo’s mind but left his soul intact. You took Greaves’s soul and left his mind perfectly functional. Which is worse? I don’t know anymore."
The vault was silent except for Edmund’s breathing.
"Marron will co before the Council tomorrow," Edmund continued. "She’ll tell them about fighting the Blade’s possession. About her tools choosing to stop their own sibling. About Lucy’s courage and Aldric’s loyalty. She’ll argue that partnership is possible with proper support, that community makes the difference."
He picked up the mandoline again, turning it over in his hands.
"And she’s not wrong. Everything she’ll say is true. The tools did choose her. She did fight back. The community did make the difference." Edmund’s voice hardened. "But she had extraordinary circumstances. A blue sli intelligent enough to fight for her. Three other Legendary Tools to restrain the fourth. A supervisor who loved her enough to tie her up. A Champion who arrived with dicine at exactly the right mont. How many other wielders will have those circumstances? One in a hundred? One in a thousand?"
He stood slowly, his knees protesting.
"I’m going to vote to confiscate the tools. Not because Marron failed—she succeeded beyond what anyone could have expected. But because her success required miracles. And we can’t build policy around miracles. We have to build it around what’s likely, what’s replicable, what’s safe for the average wielder."
Edmund walked to the iron door of Vault Seven-Seventeen, pulled it open. Inside was darkness and silence.
"You’ll go in here. You’ll stay here. And maybe in another seven hundred years, soone will find a way to safely study you. To understand what you were supposed to teach before you forgot how. To extract your wisdom without your poison." He paused. "Or maybe you’ll just rust away in the dark. Either way, you’re done teaching."
He placed the mandoline on a stone shelf inside the vault. The tool looked small there, diminished. Just tal and blades, no wielder to give it purpose.
But before he closed the door, Edmund felt it again—that sense of potential, of awareness waiting.
And underneath that: doubt.
The Slicer was questioning itself. Marron had been right about that. Whatever had happened during the fight, whatever the Blade had shown it, whatever Lucy’s emotional pulse had revealed—the mandoline was no longer certain.
Edmund could feel it through the faint resonance all Legendary Tools carried. The Slicer didn’t understand why its siblings had refused reunion. Didn’t understand why its wielder had been stopped. Didn’t understand the difference between function and wisdom.
But it knew—finally, after seven hundred years—that there was a difference.
"Maybe that’s enough," Edmund said quietly. "Maybe doubt is the first step toward wisdom. Maybe in another century or two, you’ll figure out what you forgot. Why your siblings chose separation. Why love sotis ans staying apart."
He paused at the threshold, looking at the mandoline one final ti.
"Or maybe you’ll just sit here in the dark, wondering why efficiency wasn’t enough. Why perfect uniformity didn’t equal perfect purpose. Why no one wants to partner with you anymore."
Edmund stepped back and closed the door. The iron clanged shut with a sound like finality. He pulled out four different keys—each one ornate, each one designed for a specific lock. One by one, he turned them. Four locks, four clicks, four separate seals between the Slicer and the world above.
Then he pulled out three small vials—binding spells, prepared by the Society’s only remaining mage. He poured them across the door in specific patterns, speaking words in a language older than the Cataclysm.
The first seal: To prevent unlocking from within.
The second seal: To prevent resonance with other artifacts.
The third seal: To prevent the tool from calling to potential wielders.
The spells settled into the door like frost, visible for a mont as silver lines, then fading into the tal.
"There," Edmund said. "Triple sealed. Four locked. You’re not getting out. Not in my lifeti. Probably not in anyone’s lifeti who’s currently alive."
He picked up his lantern and the empty canvas wrapping. His journal he kept—he’d need it for tomorrow’s Council session. Evidence. Docuntation. Proof that tools corrupt wielders, that the pattern repeats, that Marron’s case isn’t unique but fits perfectly into forty years of tragedy.
He climbed the stairs slowly. His hip ached—he was getting old, had been old for a while now. Eighty years of watching people fail. Eighty years of docunting what should have been learned centuries ago.
Sotis he wondered what it would be like to be young and idealistic like Marron. To believe that partnership was possible despite the evidence. To keep fighting even when the odds were impossible.
He’d been like that once. Forty-five years ago, fresh from his studies, full of ideas about how artifacts could be safely studied, safely used, safely integrated into society.
Then he’d docunted his first corruption case. Then his fifth. Then his tenth. Then Theo—his student’s best friend, the young man who’d reminded Edmund of himself at that age—had broken completely, and Edmund’s idealism had died with him.
Now he was just tired. Tired of fighting. Tired of docunting. Tired of watching young people reach for sothing beyond their grasp and fall.
But he’d do it one more ti. Tomorrow. For Marron. Because she deserved to have her case heard, even if the verdict was already decided.
Edmund reached the surface level and locked the vault entrance behind him. The keys went into his office safe. The binding spell components went back to the mage for disposal. The journal went into his desk drawer, ready for tomorrow.
He sat at his desk and stared at the wall where he kept his docuntation. Seventeen plaques, each one engraved with a na, a date, a cautionary note.
Case One: Sarah Velt - Possessed by Legendary Compass - 2985 - Deceased
Case Seven: Marcus Thorne - Corrupted by Legendary Quill - 2993 - Institutionalized
Case Fourteen: Theo Marris - Broken by Legendary Spoons - 3019 - Institutionalized
Tomorrow he’d add another plaque. Case Eighteen: Marron Louvel - Possessed by Legendary Blade - 3022 - Tools Confiscated.
Not deceased. Not institutionalized. But ended nonetheless.
Edmund pulled out paper and began writing his statent for tomorrow’s Council session. He’d been writing these statents for forty years—the argunts were practiced, polished, proven by repetition.
The wielder demonstrated clear loss of control...
The tool overrode the wielder’s will completely...
Only extraordinary intervention prevented tragedy...
We cannot base policy on miracles...
The tools must be contained for public safety...
The words flowed easily. Too easily. He’d said them so many tis they’d beco automatic, reflexive. Like Greaves’s efficiency. Like the Slicer’s perfect uniformity.
Edmund stopped writing and stared at what he’d written.
When had his warnings beco automatic? When had his fear beco reflexive? When had he stopped seeing each case as unique and started seeing them all as proof of the sa inevitable pattern?
Am I any different from the Slicer? he wondered. Teaching the sa lesson over and over—fear, containnt, prohibition—until that’s all I know how to teach? Until I’ve forgotten there might be other lessons worth learning?
The thought disturbed him. He pushed it away, returned to his statent. But the words ca slower now, each one requiring conscious effort.
Tomorrow the Council would vote. Tomorrow Marron would lose. Tomorrow the Blade, Cart, Pot, and Ladle would join the Slicer in the vaults, sealed away as evidence that partnership was impossible.
And Edmund Erwell, Director of the Historical Preservation Society, would have been proven right once again.
He should have felt satisfied. Vindicated. Protected by the knowledge that another tragedy had been prevented.
Instead, he just felt old.
Outside his window, Luria’s towers caught the moonlight. The city slept, unaware that tomorrow’s decision would set precedent for decades to co. Would determine whether future wielders ever got the chance to try what Marron had tried.
Edmund finished his statent, sealed it, set it aside for tomorrow.
Then he pulled out a second piece of paper and began to write sothing he’d never written before:
Minority Statent - For Council Record Only
Case Eighteen presents unusual circumstances. While the wielder did lose control, she also demonstrated unprecedented resistance with community support. Her tools chose wisdom over reunion. Her companion fought despite trauma. Her supervisor maintained oversight despite personal risk.
If we confiscate the tools, we prove that partnership requires miracles. But if we allow her to continue under enhanced supervision, we might prove that miracles can be made systematic.
I recomnd a third option: conditional retention with mandatory oversight. Monthly evaluations. Required companions. Community check-ins. Not freedom, but not imprisonnt. A middle path between idealism and fear.
Edmund stared at what he’d written. It was heresy. Everything he’d built for forty years, undermined by a single statent. The other councilors would think he’d gone soft. Would question his judgnt. Would wonder if he was too old, too tired, too compromised by sentint.
They’d be right to wonder.
He folded the minority statent, sealed it, and placed it in his desk drawer next to his journal.
He wouldn’t present it tomorrow. Wouldn’t undermine his own position. Wouldn’t give false hope to a young woman who’d already lost.
But he’d keep it. As a reminder that doubt—even his own carefully constructed, forty-years-tested doubt—wasn’t certainty.
That fear, no matter how well-docunted, wasn’t the sa as truth.
And that maybe, just maybe, he’d beco what he’d spent his life fighting against: so certain of his lessons that he’d forgotten to question if they were the right ones.
Reviews
All reviews (0)