What's wrong with this lawyer?! Chapter 567

Chapter 567: Chapter 185: The Problem Arises, Can You Still Count Money After Feeling Good?_4 Chapter 567: Chapter 185: The Problem Arises, Can You Still Count Money After Feeling Good?_4 Du Junfeng had been waiting in front of his computer since early, and although the ga company had said they would refund the recharges of those few days, he really didn’t feel there was anything to it.

The real big spending had been in December of last year when the new server opened, and the recharges of those few days were actually substantial.

There was a mont when he even thought that the people online were sick; such a trivial gimmick had appeased everyone, and those who claid to be players were even praising the company!

Finally, several images appeared, similar to the court’s proceedings, with the video screen showing the collegial panel, on the left were the plaintiffs Ju Haiqing and Tang Fangjing, and on the right was the representative of the defendant, the tian Company.

Both video and audio transmission were without issue, and with the words of the Judgnt Chief, “Ju Haiqing vs.

tian Company on the infringent of virtual property rights” officially began!

It was still the sa mode as offline: both parties made statents, presented evidence, and cross-examined.

...

Old Tang had made andnts to the complaint, but of course, the core was the sa, stating that tian Company’s cessation of ga operations infringed on Ju Haiqing’s virtual property rights.

The defense of tian Company was much the sa, their general argunt being that no ga can operate forever, and as a ga operator, tian Company, in accordance with legal regulations regarding the cessation of the ga in question, did not constitute infringent.

Old Tang had no reaction; these were normal steps in the course of the trial, but the netizens couldn’t stand it.

All that money spent to build up a ga account, and it’s just shut down like that, the compensation is to go play other gas?

And they only offer a refund for the recharges of the last five days?

What about all that money charged but not yet spent?

Just ignored?

And they still have the gall to claim that there has been no infringent?

During the trial, Old Tang and the others naturally couldn’t see the barrage of live comnts; by now, they had begun presenting and cross-examining evidence.

“Evidence one, Ju Haiqing’s recharge records from August of last year until the service was discontinued, proving his cumulative recharge amount is one thousand three hundred yuan,” announced one side.

“The authenticity and objectivity of this evidence are recognized, but its relevance is not,” ca the reply.

“Evidence two, screenshots of various permanent characters and permanent items in the ga, proving the existence of undetermined virtual property before the ga was shut down.”

“The authenticity of this evidence is recognized, but the objectivity and relevance are not.

Firstly, regarding the recharge departnt, apart from the remaining three thousand two hundred Virtual Coins for paid Virtual Coins, the rest of the recharge has already been consud within the legal relationship that occurred,” Zhou Xianying said very seriously.

“This is a process of legal currency—Virtual Coin—ga character and item, and as for those character and item not involving legal currency, there is no legal stipulation that they fall under virtual property, therefore they are not recognized.”

You can say a thousand, ten thousand words but if I don’t consider it virtual property, then there’s no basis for talking about property infringent.

Viewers in the live room continued to watch; the topic was novel, and having played gas for so many years, it was the first ti they had seen these things defined from a legal perspective.

Old Tang’s side began to present more evidence.

This ti it revolved around tian Company’s activities for the new servers opened in December of the previous year, as well as evidence of the compensation announcent.

It proved that tian Company’s compensation at the ti of the ga’s shutdown was inconsistent.

It’s a simple concept: the compensation implies that if you continue to play their ga, you get a return equivalent to twenty percent of your total past recharges in bound diamonds, but if you don’t continue their ga, you don’t get a single hair.

This was obviously unfair.

It was Zhou Xianying’s turn to present evidence.

“Evidence one, the user agreent, proving that tian Company is not a qualified defendant, and even if tian is a qualified defendant, according to the user agreent, the ownership of the ga account should belong to tian Company.

Therefore, tian Company’s cessation of the ga, according to legal regulations, doesn’t infringe on anyone’s rights,” she stated.

“Evidence two…”

Zhou Xianying’s side didn’t have much evidence, and it mainly revolved around the user agreent; she was trying to prove one thing—that the shutdown of the ga had nothing to do with the players, and that the accounts are owned by the company itself.

It was up to the company to decide whether or not to offer compensation.

The court investigation phase ended, and the Judgnt Chief announced to the cara: “Now begins the court debate, please, the plaintiff will express their opinions first.”

Old Tang began, “Firstly, I want to clarify why I believe that Ju Haiqing’s related ga character and items are virtual property, because these characters and items embody Ju Haiqing’s monetary and labor contributions!”

“Although these items exist in data form in specific spaces, they have value, can be controlled by people, and are a special type of property that can be traded under certain conditions.

Therefore, they possess the nature of property interests.”

The logic is simple: yes, this is a ga, but as players, we have spent money and effort on these items; these items have value, and can sotis be traded.

So, you can’t deny the property attributes of these entities.

When we talk about trading ga accounts ordinarily, is it for the account itself, or for the special characters and items on the account?

Thus, in the case of property attributes, it’s not enough for ga companies to write a sentence in the agreent claiming ownership of ga accounts to completely negate them.

“Therefore, tian Company’s shutdown of ‘Flying’ has infringed upon our party’s virtual property rights,” Old Tang declared.

On the other side, Zhou Xianying began her rebuttal, “We do not recognize the plaintiff’s contention that the items in the ga have property attributes.

Essentially, this should be considered a ga service, and when one obtains the said items, they have already enjoyed the corresponding service.”