All the spectators, the presiding judge, the judges, everyone was watching Gu Chen.
Gu Chen began, "Sun Yuxuan is a person who is diligent and hardworking, often working overti at the company just to earn a bit more money. Both neighbors and colleagues praise his good character. Sun Yuxuan even received a bravery award from the city for successfully helping to catch a robber."
"Yet, such a person was driven to a dead end."
"Why? Liu Ting, do you think your judgnt was correct?"
"From a legal standpoint, strictly speaking, there is nothing wrong with your judgnt."
"Because the law does not specify how to divide property in specific divorce cases according to different situations."
"This part falls under discretionary power."
"And you used your discretionary power to make a completely unfair judgnt!"
Gu Chen also reviewed all of Liu Ting’s previous judgnts.
Liu Ting is a presiding judge and is quite proficient in law.
Not every presiding judge is like Li Yongxia, who would take bribes or handle cases irregularly.
Such actions, once reported, would lead to severe punishnt.
Liu Ting ruled on Sun Yuxuan’s case...
Legally, indeed, no problems could be found.
But clearly, why can’t this unreasonable judgnt be legally challenged?
In divorce cases, there are several principles of property division.
The spouses can either negotiate, and as long as they agree and do not violate legal provisions, they can divide their property as they wish.
Or the court can make a ruling.
The principles of property division are as follows:
1. Principle of equality between n and won.
2. Principle of protecting the rights of children and the wife.
In traditional family models, the wife assus more household chores and child-rearing responsibilities and is relatively weaker in socio-economic status, so this principle exists in legal provisions.
3. Principle of protecting the innocent party.
4. Principle of benefiting production and facilitating life.
Special division of assets will also be conducted.
For example, real estate, stocks, equity, insurance, intellectual property rights, etc.
These are legal provisions.
But in real life, the reasons for the breakdown of relationships are diverse.
The couples’ property is complex, and other factors in real life add up to make it even more complicated.
The law struggles to delineate different situations and provide legal text interpretation.
The law prescribes so basic principles for property division ratios, such as protecting the rights of children and the wife and the innocent party.
However, there is no specific legal provision on how to divide the property.
At this point, discretionary power cos into play.
Judges can make rulings based on the circumstances of the case.
Judges can also decide the property division based on the degree of fault.
In this case...
The reason Liu Ting made such a ruling is simple.
The couple’s marital property was all awarded to Wang Ru.
Because Wang Ru is also part of the family, and she has no earning ability, and she also took on household chores and can take care of the child.
Even though Wang Ru does not currently have a child, she stated in court that she was preparing for pregnancy and working hard every day.
Liu Ting believes that a large portion of Wang Yuxuan’s submitted salary was used for the family and that he spent little on himself.
In simple terms, Wang Ru can have children and do housework, clean, wash, cook, just like a full-ti housekeeper.
Even though Wang Ru hasn’t had children yet, isn’t preparing for pregnancy also very exhausting?
Should the hardship of preparing for pregnancy be overlooked?
Even with surveillance footage...
But surveillance footage cannot possibly cover every corner of the household.
Is it possible that Wang Ru did nothing at ho?
According to Liu Ting, it’s clearly impossible.
Moreover, the surveillance footage does not prove that Wang Ru didn’t do housework, didn’t handle household chores, didn’t cook, didn’t wash dishes, or didn’t mop the floor...
Besides, regular household expenses, water, electricity, and other fees were all paid by Wang Ru.
So all the marital property was awarded to Wang Ru.
Furthermore, Sun Yuxuan has to compensate Wang Ru.
As for Sun Yuxuan’s premarital property?
After marrying Wang Ru, due to his special affection for her,
After Wang Ru’s repeated requests, Sun Yuxuan transferred the nas on the house and car to Wang Ru.
As a result, Liu Ting naturally counted the house and car as gifts from Sun Yuxuan.
Even though Wang Ru had an affair after marriage, the reasons for her infidelity...
According to Wang Ru, the reason she cheated was that Sun Yuxuan didn’t care about her, was always working overti outside, and even subjected her to dostic violence and verbal abuse.
Despite the principle of protecting the innocent party,
Liu Ting believes—
Wang Ru only made a mistake that any woman might make.
And Wang Ru made mistakes, but did Sun Yuxuan not make any?
Did Sun Yuxuan do everything right?
Did Sun Yuxuan have no faults at all?
Was it enough for Sun Yuxuan just to hand over his salary after marriage?
Did he fulfill Wang Ru’s need for emotional value, care... were those t?
rely working overti and losing temper at ho, even dostic violence...
Of course, the claim of dostic violence was casually ntioned by Wang Ru.
Shouldn’t dostic violence by Sun Yuxuan be taken seriously?
Is randomly losing temper at ho not serious?
As for cheating... what’s wrong with cheating?
Isn’t cheating also because Sun Yuxuan neglected his family and even repeatedly beat and verbally abused them, wasn’t it all due to Sun Yuxuan?
Reviews
All reviews (0)